Turkey Apple Melt – A classic turkey melt is taken up a notch with the addition of granny smith apples and a homemade Dijon honey mustard.
Sandwiches get a bad rap. They’re pushed to the side and treaty like a “lazy” option. But the truth is, sometimes I just want a comforting, classic meal that I can eat between two pieces of bread. Is that so wrong?!
I’ll admit, however, that my typical turkey sandwich can get a little boring. So I decided to snazz it up a little by adding a homemade Dijon honey mustard and tart apple and grilling it until the cheese gets nice and gooey.
And so my Turkey Apple Melt was born! Check it out!
What’s in this melt?
This melt has a few basic components: crusty bread, honey mustard, thinly sliced turkey, muenster cheese, and sliced apple. But the best part of the sandwich is how all these components work together to bring killer flavor. The mild turkey pairs so beautifully with the tart apple and gooey muenster cheese that you’ll be taking bite after bite until you realize the sandwich is all gone!
How to make this melt
Think of a melt similar to a grilled cheese but with other ingredients, usually a protein of some sort. Therefore, the cooking process is done pretty similarly. But before we cook it, we have to assemble the sandwich.
First, you’ll layer on the homemade Dijon honey mustard. It’s made by simply mixing together equal parts Dijon mustard, honey, and mayonnaise.
Then comes the cheese. Depending on the type of bread used, the cheese may not fit perfectly. But I don’t accept cheese oozing off the side because then it will burn off once we grill it in the saute pan. Instead, I rip of the pieces that are hanging over and fill in the gaps.
Next comes the slices of apple. I like putting the apple on the cheese so that the melted cheese acts as a glue to keep those apples in place. Then, the sandwich it gets finished with the thinly sliced turkey right on top.
Now that we have the sandwich assembled, it’s time for grilling. To get the crust nice and crispy, I add 1/2 tablespoon of butter to a saute pan and let it melt while the pan heats up. Once the butter is melted, it’s time to grill the sandwich. Pro tip: do not use heat higher than medium or else the bread will brown before the cheese melts.
Once you’ve browned one side, flip and brown the other side. Once the cheese has melted, remove the sandwich and serve immediately.
Tips & Tricks
- For the bread, I used sourdough, which gave the sandwich an extra boost of flavor. But you can use whichever crusty bread you prefer.
- I chose to use thinly sliced turkey because it’s easy to bite into without taking all the turkey with you and leaving two empty slices of bread.
Turkey Apple Melt
Ingredients
For the honey mustard:
- 1 tablespoon mayonnaise
- 1 tablespoon honey
- 1 tablespoon Dijon mustard
For the sandwich:
- 8 slices crusty bread
- 4 slices cheese (muenster, swiss, or cheddar work great)
- 1 medium granny smith apple sliced
Instructions
- Mix all the honey mustard ingredeints together in a small bowl. Spread on one side a piece of bread. Layer on one piece of cheese cheese, followed by apple slices, and 4 ounces of turkey. Top with other slice of bread. Repeat to create 3 more sandwiches.
- Heat skillet over medium heat. Add 1 tablespoon of butter to skillet. Once the butter has melted, add two sandwiches and let cook for 3 minutes per side or until the cheese has completely melted. Repeat with two other sandwiches. Serve immediately.
Pin for later:
More recipes you’ll love:
Turkey Cranberry Pinwheels
Mexican Street Corn Chicken Salad
Chicken Ranch Wraps
Now this is a sandwich I’d be excited about! As a high school teacher, I am always on the go, scarfing down a sandwich whenever I get the chance during the busy school day. If I bring this to work…. this changes my attitude on snacking on sandwiches! Something to look forward to at lunchtime! YUM!
I’m sure this is sandwich will be as tasty as it looks. Turkey and apples is such a unique and interesting combination. It sure would be a hit with my kids.
This is a new go-to lunch for me. I am always busy and on the go that I forget to make a filling lunch. the apples added to it is a great idea.
I love a little sweet in my sandwich – cranberry sauce is a favourite of mine – but have never tried raw slices of apple! I bet it goes perfectly with the turkey, crust bread and that tasty looking homemade honey dijon! I know what I’m making for lunch!
What is it about tasted sandwiches that makes them so good? I love the idea of apple!
Quick and easy yet delicious lunch box idea. It is so hard to find ideas for lunch and especially for school days. Got it now!!!
I love sandwiches and I think they make a great breakfast lunch or dinner. Some great tasting ingredients between two slices of bread is always a win-win for me. Looking at your list of ingredients, it would be helpful to put the turkey in it. I did see that you have it in the directions. The apples really give the sandwich a great touch.
I have only just got into putting apples into salads and I never thought of putting apple into a sandwich! I do love turkey and cheese though, so will be having this for my lunch this week!
Looks like the ultimate sandwich! apple and turkey go so well together, definitely saving this one to try very soon!
This looks fantastic! I think I may use brie and add a few slices of bacon. Yum!
I am loving the crunch of this sandwich! I also can’t wait to whip together the homemade mustard.
What an awesome turkey sandwich makeover! I love the crisp apples being a part of the sandwich. I’m definitely going to try this.
Sounds interesting and definitely amazing snack as well as tiffin option too. I love the combination, making this super delicious and unique.
I love the idea of a gourmet sandwich that can be fixed at home. The extra crunch of the apples would just take this sandwich over the top!
This looks like it would taste so delicious! I am not the best cook but I think I could even make this (which makes it even better in my opinion)! Love that you added an apple, I can only imagine how that tastes on the sandwich!
I’m loving the sound of apples and turkey as a combo! This looks so delicious!
Toasted bread sandwiches always come out best. I wonder if this recipe would work on a panini press too…? Surely it would, don’t you think?
The golden crispy bread is calling to me! What a delicious melt…I love how simple these are to make for a quick bite to eat. Apple and turkey is a wonderful combo.
Sandwiches are totally underrated! I’m a fan too. I LOVE the idea of adding apples and making this into a melt. Great recipe!
This is my kind of sandwich! I will be sure to make it for lunch one day. My family will love it.
I’ve never had apple in a sandwich before. I’ll have to try this!